Palapa or pergola? How to choose

NIPA synthetic palm thatch roof: Tulum gazebo on a stone terrace with loungers

Palapa vs pergola? If you need full shade and rain protection with a tropical feel, choose a palapa; if you only want partial shade and a light structure for climbing plants or curtains, a pergola is enough. Metal sheeting is the simplest roof covering but the least attractive, and a concrete roof is permanent, heavy and needs more structure and permits. With NIPA synthetic thatch, a palapa adds a fully waterproof roof covering with a 20-year warranty against rot, deterioration and sudden color loss.

In this guide we compare each option for creating shaded spaces in homes, restaurants and hotels, with a table and the questions we receive most often. NIPA®, direct manufacturer of synthetic thatch since 2010, helps you decide with facts.

Palapa vs pergola: what is the difference?

When comparing a palapa vs pergola, the difference is the roof. A palapa has a closed, pitched palm thatch roof that gives full shade and sheds water. A pergola is a structure of posts and open beams, sometimes with crossbars or lattice, that gives partial shade: sun and shadows that shift during the day.

Pergolas and porticos are variations on the same idea: open structures that accompany a façade, a walkway or a terrace. Pergolas can be covered with canvas, polycarbonate, metal sheeting or thatch; once covered with thatch, they start to work like a palapa.

Poolside gazebo with a railing and NIPA synthetic palm thatch

Roof comparison table

This table sums up what matters most when choosing. The figures in the NIPA column are factory specifications; in the other columns we describe the general behavior of each system, which varies with the design and the builder.

CriterionPalapa with NIPA synthetic thatchUncovered pergolaMetal sheet roofTile palapaConcrete roof
ShadeFullPartialFullFullFull
RainFully waterproof, minimum pitch 18°No protectionProtectsProtectsProtects with waterproofing
Heat under the roofFull, ventilated shadeLots of ventilationMetal sheeting in the sun tends to transmit heatDepends on the designStores heat and releases it at night
StructureLight: wood or metal with open battensLightLightHeavierHeavy, with structural calculation
Wind260 km/h, installed to NIPA specificationsDepends on the designDepends on the fixingDepends on the designDepends on the design
MaintenanceLower maintenance: periodic inspection and cleaningSealing the woodCorrosion checksChecking the piecesPeriodic waterproofing
AtmosphereTropical, resort-styleGarden, terraceUtilitarianColonial, rusticUrban
Warranty20 years against rot, deterioration and sudden color lossDepends on the builderDepends on the manufacturerDepends on the manufacturerDepends on the builder

Concrete roof or palapa: which is better?

The question of concrete roof or palapa comes up a lot for terraces and restaurants. A concrete roof is permanent and works as a slab, but it is heavy, needs structural calculation, formwork and permits, and creates an urban feel. A palapa is lighter, quicker to build and creates the tropical atmosphere guests and customers look for.

For a restaurant terrace, a palapa with NIPA synthetic thatch gives full shade, rain protection and, in the FR model, a Class A rating under ASTM E108, something many commercial projects ask for.

What is a concrete palapa?

It is a concrete slab shaped like a palapa (round or hip-roofed), sometimes textured or painted to imitate palm thatch. A concrete palapa is durable, but it has neither the texture nor the look of thatch. Some owners later cover it with thatch to achieve the natural look. With NIPA synthetic thatch, you work as on an existing metal roof or wall: first battens are fixed at 22 cm on the surface, then the panels are screwed on, always with a minimum pitch of 18°; the anchors are specified by the project engineer.

Pyramid wooden kiosk with NIPA synthetic palm thatch in a garden

Is a metal sheet roof a good idea for a palapa?

A metal sheet roof for a palapa is cheap and quick, but it doesn't look like a palapa. Sheet-roofed palapas include painted metal sheeting, galvanized sheeting, polycarbonate sheeting and tile-effect sheeting. Sheeting protects from rain, although it tends to be noisy in a downpour and, exposed to the sun, can transmit heat downward.

If you already have a structure with metal sheeting and want the look of thatch, NIPA synthetic thatch can go on top: battens are fixed at 22 cm over the existing metal or PVC sheeting and the panels are screwed onto them, with a minimum pitch of 18°. For more on temperature, see our guide to synthetic thatch and heat.

Can you build a thatch pergola roof?

Yes. A pergola with a thatch roof combines the best of both: the pergola structure and the full shade of a palapa. The condition is that the roof is pitched: a flat pergola does not shed water. For a pergola with NIPA synthetic thatch, the frame needs at least 18° of pitch and horizontal battens.

Thatch pergolas are used in hotel corridors, home terraces and restaurant bars. Many people call this mix a palapa pergola or palapa-pergola: pergola posts and beams with a pitched thatch roof covering.

Square spa pergola with a fire table and NIPA synthetic palm thatch

Tile palapa or palm rancho?

A tile palapa uses clay or concrete tiles on a sturdier structure. In Nicaragua and El Salvador people talk about ranchos of palm or tile, and typical ranchos with palm and tile roofs, depending on the region. Tile gives a colonial look; thatch gives the beach atmosphere.

If you are looking for synthetic palm thatch, cane and tiles from a single supplier, note that NIPA specializes in synthetic palm thatch: the most realistic synthetic thatch, molded from real palm leaves, in several shades and with two molds to avoid repeating patterns.

Which option gives the longest-lasting shaded spaces?

For durable palapas and pergolas, the roof covering is what wears most. Natural palm is replaced often; metal sheeting corrodes near the sea; a pergola's wood needs sealing. NIPA synthetic thatch passed 5,000 hours of ASTM G155 testing at Micom Laboratories, an independent laboratory in Canada, with no significant color change; our own factory laboratory has also tested it beyond 10,000 hours with the ASTM G154 method. It keeps its original color for decades and has a 20-year warranty.

To explore the other shapes and structures, see our guide to palapa designs, and to compare all roofing materials, our complete thatch roof guide.

Square palapa with a bench and wooden posts, NIPA synthetic palm thatch roof

Building palapas and pergolas: who to work with

Many builders offer carpentry, decks, palapas and pergolas in one package. NIPA Palma, NIPA's regional office for Mexico and Latin America, supplies them with synthetic thatch factory direct, with local quotes and installation support.

If you build palapas and pergolas, or are looking for custom pergola and palapa construction, send us the drawing and we will calculate pieces and boxes: 5.2 pieces per m² of roof and boxes of 70 pieces covering about 13.5 m². For palapa and pergola projects in Los Cabos and the rest of Baja California Sur, we also quote your project. To see how much to invest, check the synthetic thatch prices. We supply NIPA synthetic thatch for:

  • Palapas and pergolas for beach houses and gardens.
  • Palapas and pergolas for restaurants, beach clubs and hotels.
  • Custom palapa and pergola construction with wood or metal structures.
  • Building kiosks, bohíos, pergolas, decks, palapas, cabins and other structures with thatch roofs.

Frequently asked questions

How much does it cost to build a concrete palapa?

It depends on the size, the structural calculation, the formwork and local labor, so ask a builder in your area for a quote. If you are comparing it with a NIPA synthetic thatch palapa, send us the size and we will quote the roof covering.

Which gives more shade, a palapa or a pergola?

The palapa: its thatch roof is continuous and gives full shade. An uncovered pergola gives partial shade, unless a roof is added.

Do you work with pergola and palapa builders in Los Cabos?

We quote projects for pergola and palapa builders all over Mexico, including Los Cabos, with direct shipping from the factory.

Palapa, pergola or shade sail for shade?

A shade sail (tensioned canvas) is light and modern, but it lacks the tropical atmosphere of thatch. A palapa gives full shade and rain protection; a pergola, partial shade.

Keep reading

Decided between palapa vs pergola? Get a quote for your thatch roof

Send us the size and shape through our contact page and we will reply with pieces, boxes and shipping. WhatsApp +1 (863) 243-0114 · sales@nipapalma.com.

In this article

    Stay in touch

    Let’s talk about your project

    Tell us about your project and see how synthetic thatch can be integrated into your spaces with aesthetics, functionality and timeless style.

    Keep exploring